I watched yesterday's Xarabank programme through the streaming available on di-ve.com, because I wanted to write about it and I can't really criticise if I don't actually know what happened. I didn't watch the programme live because in our house, Friday night is for the Living TV line-up of Moonlight followed by Criminal Minds followed by CSI. Priorities...
So, I watched the entire programme tonight and followed along by writing a transcript, and then extracted the major themes. I've put the list of themes at the very, very bottom of this post - it's a long one!
Xarabank focused mostly on relationships, probably because human interest stories make for good ratings. They spent quite a lot of time talking about social networking sites, in particular Hi5, and chatrooms (mostly mIRC). There were three sweet stories about people meeting friends/boyfriends/spouses online and then In Real Life, but mostly the programme was about the evils of the internet. Porn, bullying, the exploitation of children by strangers, scams, hate sites, online gambling were all mentioned. Blogs were not mentioned at all. Education via the internet was not mentioned. The ability to do good via the internet was not mentioned. Pursuing hobbies and finding support in difficulty such as illness were not mentioned. There were huge gaping holes in the programme, which is a shame, and calling it "Cyperspace" was too general. Really there is enough material about the internet to cover multiple episodes - if they can do one episode about the evils of the internet, wouldn't it be great to follow with another episode about all the cool things you can do online?
At the beginning of this programme, there wasn't even a brief explanation about what the internet is, so I imagine that most viewers over a certain age probably watched with bemusement.
There was a panel, and a couple of other guests. Of the panelists, only ONE seemed to be a geek, or at least familiar with the use of the internet (he used expressions like IRL), and it was nice to see him jumping in with some good points such as there are other bad sites on the Net other than porn sites, and that people do bad things to each other offline as well as on. Of the rest of the panelists, most of them had an axe to grind about some particular aspect of The Evil On The Internet. A couple of times different people said "the internet can be used for good things too but..." and we never got to hear about those good things.
My point is, yes people should know about the bad stuff that is out there, but by only focusing on one side you leave the viewers with a bad impression. Overall there were some good points raised about online safety, which is great, and any non-savvy parents who were watching now have a better idea about helping their children stay safe online. But I wish that the programme had been more balanced, by covering some positive topics or having more geeky people up there.
I loved the clips from the Cyber Crimes unit, the guys did a great job explaining how they monitor social networking sites, how to check the authenticity of scam emails, and what happens when a computer is impounded. I had no idea they were checking up on social networks, I think that's a great idea.
Because I was bored, earlier in the week when I knew the theme of the Xarabank programme and of its probable bias, I wrote the following about how I use the Internet as part of my life. There's loads of people like me whose internet use is not limited to Hi5 and mIRC, but maybe we're not interesting enough ;-)